Blog Archive

About Me

Friday, November 4, 2011

postheadericon Copyright Industries Massive Success Shows That They're Dying And Need More Draconian Copyright Laws?

an annual report on the "size" of the "copyright industries" by the "International Intellectual Property Alliance" (a trade group composed of trade groups, including the RIAA, MPAA, BSA, ESA, NMPA and others), there are many problems with this report. First, it is assumed ridiculously bad that "copyright industries" are only because of copyright . It is, using the size numbers suggest that the strengthening of copyright is required. However, this is ridiculous. They have no evidence that the industries of all sizes to be different, if the copyright laws are weaker or more heavy. Simply present this as the obvious implication. Moreover, his definition of what constitutes "copyright industries" is incredibly broad, and tends to include a large number of operations that do not really want stricter laws Copyright to all. For example, I'm sure Techdirt technically eligible for any measure you use. After all, is a publisher, so technically we are in "the content industries." However, I can tell you right now exactly

zero percent of our revenue is due to copyright law. This is true of many, many companies as "copyright industries".



Unfortunately, this myth persists that if you add all the broad "content industries" shows in a way why you need more stringent copyright. But that does not make sense. If in fact shown a direct causal relationship - or even any

proof that the copyright policy leads directly to the overall income, could have any argument. But do not go near these things. But can not stand on the issue. With the latest release, Senators Sheldon Whitehouse and Orrin Hatch, with Congressmen Bob Goodlatte and Adam Schiff, welcomed the various pressure groups which produced this report (ie the head of the ESA, NMPA, RIAA and MPAA) to encourage reporting and use it to falsely claim it is proof that more draconian copyright laws are important.

It makes no sense and frankly, it insults the intelligence of most people, say that the total income within an industry is the automatic indicator of how the policy should be determined by the industry. To determine policies based on the deltas, not absolute.


It gets even worse if you look in the current report, which shows the industry in question done extremely well
. In fact, as many are taking note, the report seems to actually undermine the whole argument of the industry as "piracy" is somehow decimate their business. Instead - even through a recession, companies are a lot of money, and no evidence of job loss.
is a very small movement when our leaders in Congress and then take the points that are simply not compatible with the need for copyright in any way ... more and then used to support these policies. Each year, of course, the ICAC released a report showing that if this is how it will calculate "copyright industries", which is just using the same methodology for calculating the industries that are built from "exceptions to copyright," which turns out to be much larger than "copyright industries". So if any of the elected officials praising the latter report are intellectually honest, they really should be the defense of the weak copyright. After all, the same methodology shows that
Find best price for : --copyright--

0 comments: